Nopalea At The Spa

By Frank Yaconis

Nopalea Juice, which is made from the Prickly Pear Cactus, appears to be one of the most useful plants in the world for human consumption. You can eat it, you can drink it and now you can be massaged by it. Apparently, a Mexican luxury resort treats its interested guests to massages with a prickly free version of the plant mixed with Agave and tequila.

A cactus massage is only one of the interesting services offered to guests at spas around the world. Adventurous spa goers can also see out the following services, that include obtaining a fish pedicure, where fish eat the dead skin off your feet; a snake massage where a masseuse dribbles one or two snakes on your back and lets them slither around; a facial made from thin gold strips laid on the face, which is said to have originated with Cleopatra; a rear-end buffing and waxing procedure; and bathing in a pool of wine or a vat of beer.

For those of us who view the cactus as a food and medicine (it is renowned for its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties), there are many ways to ingest it.

The prickly pear cactus grows all across North America, where it is a native species, but it has also been transplanted around the world. But remember it is a native to Mexico and the southern United States.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdq85gUJ0R0[/youtube]

Its use as a food and medicine dates back to the Aztecs who also ate it and harvested it for its medicinal qualities.

If you want to drink the plant for its benefits, the easiest method is to buy Nopalea Juice, which is an all-natural mixture that combines the cactus with Agave juice and several other tasty and healthy fruits. It is overflowing with a variety of vitamins and minerals.

There are many ways to eat the plant. You can grill, broil, fry or boil the pads, which are called Nopalitos. They are delicious and taste a bit like asparagus or green beans. Many people just add oil or butter and eat them plain this way. By the way, nopalitos means cactus stem.

The fruit of the prickly pear cactus (which is where the term “pear” comes from) can also be eaten. The plant erupts into beautiful blossoms, as well that are yellow, purple or red. They are also edible.

Did you know that the meat and fruit and blossoms from the cactus are made into numerous foods? They are used for making candy, with tuna in a salad, in chili, stews, salads, salsas and even soups. Authentic Mexican restaurants will almost always have them on the menu. A very popular way for a restaurant to serve the cactus is with eggs or in tacos. With eggs, they are called heuvos con Nopales, if you see that you know it is the cactus.

The cactus is very good for you — so nutritious. It is chock full of dietary fiber and has numerous vitamins and minerals. It is a great way to eat something healthy, while you are also taking steps to prevent future diseases and ailments. Good for your body now and later.

About the Author: Frank Yocanis has been researching and writing about the health benefits of

Nopalea Cactus

for the past decade. He has even traveled to the Sonoran desert half a dozen times to study

Nopalea

in the plant’s homeland. He is excited to share how this antioxidant-rich drink can change your life.

Source:

isnare.com

Permanent Link:

isnare.com/?aid=705945&ca=Wellness%2C+Fitness+and+Diet

Interview: Drupal founder Dries Buytaert balances community and company interests

Sunday, February 24, 2008

In the year 2000, Dries Buytaert created Drupal, a freely licensed and open source tool to manage websites, as a bulletin board for his college dorm. Since Dries released the software and a community of thousands of volunteer developers have added and improved modules, Drupal has grown immensely popular. Drupal won the overall Open CMS Award in 2007, and some speakers in Drupal’s spacious developer’s room at FOSDEM 2008 were dreaming aloud of its world domination.

Buytaert (now 29) just finished his doctoral thesis and has founded the start-up Acquia. The new company wants to become Drupal’s best friend, with the help of an all-star team and US$7 million collected from venture capitalists. Wikinews reporter Michaël Laurent sat down with Dries in Brussels to discuss these recent exciting developments.

Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=Interview:_Drupal_founder_Dries_Buytaert_balances_community_and_company_interests&oldid=4635194”

Wikinews interviews Kristian Hanson, producer-director of indie horror film ‘Sledge’

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Just days away from Halloween, Wikinews interviewed Kristian Hanson, producer-director of independent slasher film Sledge. The film has been a recent source of discussion in horror fan circles, primarily due to its production budget of only US$800. Sledge is Hanson’s fourth film to direct, according to Internet Movie Database.

Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=Wikinews_interviews_Kristian_Hanson,_producer-director_of_indie_horror_film_%27Sledge%27&oldid=4567509”

The Wii, Nintendo’s next generation console, launches in North America

Sunday, November 19, 2006

Nintendo has released its newest video game console in North America. Known as the Wii, the system and games have an MSRP of US$249.99 and US$49.99 respectively. The North American release is to be followed by the December 2nd launch in Japan and the December 8th launch in Europe.

Launched officially at midnight, more than a thousand people gathered in New York’s Time Square to be among the first to buy one of the Wii. In contrast to the crowds that have challenged crowd control officials over the last two days in connection with the launch of Sony’s Playstation 3, the Wii crowds have been much calmer. Many observers attribute this to the fact that Nintendo had more than ten times as many Wii consoles available on launching day than Sony did for their PS3 that had been hounded by part shortages in manufacturing right up to the day of launch.

Nintendo of America president Reggie Fils-Aime said that several tough choices had been made in the design of the Wii. The company decided to develop a new way of playing games with revolutionary controllers instead of following the PS3 and the Xbox down the road of stunning graphic and multimedia options. This produced a console with a much talked-about sensor/controller design and the lowest price point of the three major consoles. While not having a DVD player or high-definition TV capabilities, the Wii retails for about $250 while its competitors the Xbox 360 and PS3 retail for about $400 and $600 respectively.

While the Wii will launch with several games available, one of its advertised advantages is that the new console is largely compatible with older games made for the GameCube, giving the new console an instant and extensive launching library. A GameCube controller will be needed to play GameCube games with the Wii. Several hardware items that GameCube games may be expecting, such as the modem or broadband adapter or the GameBoy player are not supported on the Wii.

Across the country in Los Angeles about 500 people were waiting for the doors to open at Universal City Walk’s Game Stop store. Fearing that the Wii introduction might be as contentious as the PS3 debut just a few days ago, the store handed out numbered wristbands to the throng. No problems were reported.

Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=The_Wii,_Nintendo%27s_next_generation_console,_launches_in_North_America&oldid=567132”

Tips On How To Get Cheap Car Insurance In Tulsa Ok

byAlma Abell

Have you been searching for Cheap Car Insurance in Tulsa OK? If so, you’re not alone. Every day there are thousands of drivers who actively search for ways to lower their auto insurance rates. Unfortunately, most people struggle to significantly reduce their rates, and feel like they will be stuck paying high insurance premiums forever. If you’re one of the many people who are tired of paying high insurance rates, you should know there are several tips you can follow to greatly reduce your insurance rates.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzdDl778feU[/youtube]

One thing you can do to get Cheap Car Insurance in Tulsa OK, is to get a multi-policy discount. If you’re not familiar with what a multi-policy discount is, it is simply when you group multiple insurance products together. For example, if you currently have a car and a motorcycle, purchasing coverage from the same company could reduce your rates by about twenty percent. You can also reduce your insurance rates if you lower the amount of insurance coverage you have. For example, if your vehicle is more than fifteen years old, reducing your coverage to liability only could reduce your costs by up to fifty percent.

Another thing you can do to get cheaper insurance is to shop around. There are more insurance companies than ever before, and most of them are willing to compete with your current carrier to get your business. Many people have also found they are able to reduce their insurance rates by increasing the deductible hey have on their policy. If you currently have a five hundred dollar deductible, increasing it to at least one thousand dollars could reduce your rates by up to ten percent. Improving your credit score can also reduce the amount you have to pay for car insurance, too.

As you can see, there are several things you can do to get cheaper car insurance. If you’re tired of paying high rates, and are ready to get a quote from another company, you should contact AES Insurance Brokers. They will happily provide you with a free quote over the telephone, or you can look at this website to get a quote as well. Keep in mind that if you’re interested in other insurance products, such as homeowners insurance or boat insurance, this company is happy to get you quotes for these products, too.

Niece of Scientology’s leader goes public with criticism

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

The niece of the Church of Scientology‘s top leader David Miscavige has come forward publicly with criticism of the organization and of Scientology practices. Jenna Miscavige Hill, daughter of David Miscavige’s older brother Ron Miscavige, described Scientology policies which broke apart her family and continue to keep members of her family from talking to each other. Hill criticized Scientology practices in a letter to a public relations spokeswoman for the Church of Scientology and in a broadcast of the television program Inside Edition which aired Tuesday, and was interviewed by an investigative journalist for the New York Post.

Hill wrote an open letter addressed to Karin Pouw, Public Affairs Director of the Church of Scientology International, in response to a 15-page statement issued by Pouw on January 14 which was highly critical of Andrew Morton‘s new book on prominent Scientologist Tom Cruise, Tom Cruise: An Unauthorized Biography. Hill’s letter was posted to the Internet newsgroup alt.religion.scientology on January 25, and has since been widely posted on other Internet message boards.

I am absolutely shocked at how vehemently you insist upon not only denying the truths that have been stated about the church in that biography, but then take it a step further and tell outright lies.

In Pouw’s statement on Morton’s book, she called it a “bigoted defamatory assault replete with lies”. In her letter to Pouw, Hill responded “I am absolutely shocked at how vehemently you insist upon not only denying the truths that have been stated about the church in that biography, but then take it a step further and tell outright lies.” Specifically, Hill rebuked the Church of Scientology’s denial of a practice called “disconnection“, where members are instructed to sever all ties with friends and family who are critical of Scientology and deemed a “Suppressive Person“, or SP.

Hill wrote that it was this particular policy which broke up her family when she was 16, going on to detail how the Church of Scientology restricted her communications with her parents: “Not only was I not allowed to speak to them, I was not allowed to answer a phone for well over a year, in case it was them calling me.”

The church does not respond to newsgroup postings.

When contacted for a comment on Hill’s letter, Karin Pouw told the Agence France-Presse: “The church stands by its statement of 14 January. The church does not respond to newsgroup postings.” Hill explained her motivation for writing the letter to the Agence France-Presse: “My intention is to put it on a public forum so they are pressured into changing their ways — even if it is just to cover for themselves.”

In a broadcast of the television program Inside Edition which aired Tuesday, Hill spoke with reporter Les Trent about Scientology’s disconnection policy. Hill described a pregnant friend whose parents are still members of the Church of Scientology; but will not speak with her: “She lives in L.A. – her parents live right around the hill from her, you know she tried to call them when she was having her first child, and they were like: ‘No, sorry, I can’t speak to you.'” The Church of Scientology told Inside Edition that the allegation made by Hill is “the opposite of what the church believes and practices.” Hill last spoke to her uncle David Miscavige four years ago, around the same time that she viewed a promotional video featuring Tom Cruise, at an awards ceremony. This video was recently leaked to the Internet and appeared on the video sharing site YouTube. YouTube took the video down due to a legal complaint from the Church of Scientology, but though the website Gawker.com received a similar legal complaint, Gawker has stated that the video is newsworthy and will not be removed.

Just as L. Ron Hubbard’s family was rocked with turmoil, so it seems is Miscavige’s.

Prominent free speech activist and critic of Scientology David S. Touretzky commented on these recent developments, in an interview Wednesday with Wikinews reporter Nicholas Turnbull: “She has nothing to do with Chanology [the recent anti-Scientology movement that has gathered on Internet message boards], but what we’re seeing here is a “perfect storm” of entheta [material considered negative by Scientology]. It’s all coming together in a chain reaction: The Tom Cruise video, Andrew Morton’s bio, Kirstie Alley’s craziness, Kimora Lee Simmons, Jenna Miscavige, and there’s more to come!” Another critic of Scientology, Mark Bunker of the website XenuTV.com, compared the recent revelations to troubles in Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard‘s family: “Just as L. Ron Hubbard’s family was rocked with turmoil, so it seems is Miscavige’s.” Bunker commented on the Inside Edition piece: “This is a jaw-dropping TV segment — although Inside Edition clearly didn’t understand just how important a story they had.”

In an interview published Wednesday in the New York Post, Hill stated that she has been harassed by the Church of Scientology for speaking out against the organization: “The church has contacted several of my friends, telling them that I am smearing the church and I am going to be declared a suppressive person and asking my friends if they would disconnect from me and, in at least one case, insisting that they do.” The New York Post attempted to contact Karin Pouw for a comment, but she did not respond in time for their publication.

Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=Niece_of_Scientology%27s_leader_goes_public_with_criticism&oldid=1053968”

Civilians testify to Halliburton fraud, coercion

June 28, 2005

The Democratic Party held a public committee, aired on C-SPAN 3, at which former civilian employees based in or administering operations in Iraq, testified to specific instances of waste, fraud, and other abuses and irregularities by Halliburton and its subsidiary Kellogg, Brown and Root (KBR).

Allegations of fraud by Halliburton, specifically with regard to its operations in Iraq, have persisted since before the Iraq War. The associations between U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney and Halliburton, have been the basis for repeated speculation over possible political improprieties and business profiteering from the war.

Among the senators and representatives present at the hearing were Byron Dorgan (presiding), Henry Waxman, Frank Lautenberg, and Mark Dayton.

Among those testifying were Bunny Greenhouse, former Chief Contracting Officer of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Rory Mayberry, former Food Program Manager for Halliburton subsidiary, and Allan Waller, of the Lloyd-Owen International security and operations firm.

Greenhouse, who provided the bulk of testimony, spoke for several minutes about her involvement in the evaluation and crafting of government Army contracts, and how explaining how superiors undermined and dismissed her concerns of illegal business practices. “Ultimately my main concern was the repeated insistence that the Rio contract be awarded to KBR without competitive bidding,” Greenhouse said. She testified to have been given misinformation in answer to her complaints, and being “overtly misled” by KBR managers.

Mayberry, still in Iraq, testified by video from questions prepared by the committee. He said that KBR routinely sold expired food rations to the Army. The interviewer asked, “Are you saying that Halliburton deliberately falsified the number of meals they prepared and then submitted false claims for reimbursement and that they did this to make up for past amounts auditors had disallowed?” Mayberry firmly answered “Yes.” He said that serving expired food ration was “an everyday occurrence, sometimes every meal.” He explained that Halliburton systematically overcharged for the number of meals as well, saying, “they were charging for 20,000 meals and they were only serving 10,000 meals.” Dorgan later commented, “obviously there’s no honor here, by a company that would serve outdated food to our troops in Iraq.”

Mayberry also claimed would-be whistleblowers were threatened “to be sent to Falluja” and other “places under fire” if they talked to media or governmental oversight officials. In 2003 and 2004, Falluja had been well known as dangerous for foreign troops and civilians. “I personally was sent to Falluja for three weeks. The manager told me that I was being sent away until the auditors were gone, because I had talked to the auditors,” Mayberry said.

“The threat of being sent to a camp under fire was their way of keeping us quiet. The employees who talked to auditors were sent to camps under more fire than other camps, and Anaconda.” This report led Dorgan and others to voice considerable outrage that U.S. citizens would be personally threatened with harm for talking to oversight officials or media.

Allan Waller testified to specific examples of how KBR officials had conspired in blocking Lloyd-Owen fuel transports, and using other coercive means against its competitor. The British Lloyd-Owen has a direct contract with the Iraq government to provide fuel to various parts of the country.

In his introductory remarks, Dorgan explained that Senate Republicans had blocked or ignored any requests by Democrats to have a formal bipartisan hearing, resulting in the need for an independent committee.

Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=Civilians_testify_to_Halliburton_fraud,_coercion&oldid=1358432”

UK public sector workers strike over pension rights

Wednesday, March 29, 2006Local Government workers in the UK withdrew their labour yesterday as part of a dispute over pension entitlements. The members of 11 different trades unions were involved in the 24hr strike. As the day began they declared that support for the strike was solid. Although the strikers work for local councils, their pay and conditions are agreed nationally. The Local Government Association which represents the local councils in England and Wales declared predictions that 1.5 million people would stay away from work as “wildly optimistic”.

The Unions’ complaint is that local government workers are being treated unfavourably compared to other public sector employees. They say that agreements on pensions that have been reached with civil servants, teachers and health workers will allow those staff to continue to retire at 60 while local government staff will be forced to work until they are 65. Civil servants work for national government, teachers work for local councils but have their own pension arrangements and most health workers are employed by the state-controlled National Health Service.

The Local Government Association claims that if council workers continue to be able to retire at 60, it will increase the levels of Council Tax (a tax on people living in properties which funds a proportion of local government expenditure) by 2%.

The striking workers provide a wide range of services from assisting teachers in the class room, through inspecting kitchens for hygiene to provising care to the vulnerable in society. In some places council workers collect tolls for road tunnels or manage ferries. Mainstream media have reported on the strike all day with heavy coverage of disruption to commuters where transport has been affected. The unions have emphasised the large number of their members who are women working in low paid jobs.

The Government which regulates the scheme claimed that the early retirement provisions (called the rule of 85) were age-discriminatory and had to be removed.

The strike ended at midnight. The Unions have not declared any further strike days.

The Unions involved were AEP, AMICUS, CYWU, GMB, NAPO, NIPSA, NUJ, NUT, TGWU, UCATT and UNISON.

  • “Unison Pensions Campaign” — Unison, 28 March 2006
  • “Pensions strike bites across UK” — BBC, 28 March 2006
  • LGA Media Office. “Union demands for pension scheme will cost council taxpayers more than 2% extra a year” — Local Government Association, 28 March 2006
  • “ODPM STATEMENT ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT PENSIONS” — Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, 28 March 2006
  • “Unions fighting together to protect our pensions” — Joint Union Strike Team, 28 March 2006
Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=UK_public_sector_workers_strike_over_pension_rights&oldid=4627131”

Top 15 Cryptocurrency Exchange Clone Website Scripts

Now, let us look at some of thecrypto exchange clone scripts provided by Bitdeal in detail.

15 clone script to start your crypto exchange like binance, bitstamp and more#1 Binance Clone Script It is a website script that comprises of all the properties and features of the topmost crypto exchange Binance. Check demo ofbinance clone script

Why as like Binance?Binance is a Japan-based crypto exchange platform that supports for more than 100+ crypto-coins. It provides its exchange services all over the globe and has 4 million active users per day.Binance is multi-language support and high-frequency trading systems.

#2 Bitstamp Clone Script A clone website script, that consist of all the features of the top bitcoin exchange bitstamp.

Highlights of Bitstamp Bitstamp is a European cryptocurrency exchange platform, founded in 2011.Bitstamp is known for guaranteed trading, trustworthy fund security, trading speed, user-friendliness, and less likely to hack features.It charges 0.25% as a service fee and reaches annual revenue of around $17.9M.

#3 Bithump Clone Script

It is a website clone script, that has all the existing features, trading plug-ins of Bithumb exchange platform.

Why like Bithump?

Bithump was the first launched Korean-based cryptocurrency exchange platform currently owned and maintained by a South Korean company BTC Korea.com Co Ltd.Bithump provides security features like 2 verification to make withdrawal, SMS notifications, KYC compulsory and many other aspects.It also provides coupons, price notifications, and all time customer support

#4 Coinbase Clone ScriptIt is a website clone script that has all the existing and enhanced features, trading plug-ins as like coinbase.

Highlights of Coinbase

Coinbase is a US-based crypto exchange that supports for both fiat-to-crypto coins and crypto-to-crypto-coins. Coinbase hits an annual revenue of $ 1 billion USD in 2017 and makes the highest revenue every year. Coinbase has 13,300,000 + active users approximately and uses AES-256 encryption method for the security process.

#5 Bitfinex Clone ScriptIt is a website script that comprises of all the factors present in the top-most exchange Bitfinex.

Why like Bitfinex?Bitfinex is a platform that allows professionals to trade cryptocurrencies, owned by iFinex Inc. and located in Hong-Kong.Bitfinex is known for its features like margin trading, margin funding, orders placement, exchange,etc.,.

#6 Poloniex Clone Script

A website clone script that has all the existing and enhanced features, trading plug-ins like Poloniex.

Highlights of Poloniex

Poloniex is a pure crypto-crypto exchange platform that offers advanced trading options with maximum security for traders. It purely supports for crypto to crypto exchanges alone.Poloniex is the best and user-friendly US Based exchange which extend its trading services all over the globe.

#7 Okex Clone Script It is a website clone script that consists of all existing features of OKEX platform with additional features and plug-ins.

Why like Okex?Okex is an exchange platform that supports centralized digital assets exchange and it is Malta-based Crypto Exchange Platform that supports for only cryptocurrency payments.It is a leading global cryptocurrency exchange that provides a safe, reliable and trusted environment for digital assets tradingOKEX provides margin trading, Security Response Center, low transaction charges and lot more.

#8 Paxful Clone ScriptA website clone script to start an exchange like paxful.

Why as like Paxful?Paxful is a US-based platform that allows for cryptocurrency exchange and also for buying Bitcoin as like Local Bitcoin. Paxful is a US-based crypto platform launched in 2015, which allows for simple, fair and secure trading and which supports for more than 300 payment methods. Paxful involves many verification steps to make a secured transaction and it doesn’t provide its services in some countries.

#9 Krakenn Clone Script It is a website script that has all existing properties of Krakenn exchange platform to start your own exchange as like Krakenn.

Highlights of KrakennKrakenn is one of the leading US-Based cryptocurrency exchange platform established in 2011.Krakenn, the top cryptocurrency exchange that makes high revenue and has higher trade volume than other exchanges and provides service all over the world.

#10 Upbit Clone ScriptA website clone script that has the features and API’s as like upbit cryptocurrency exchange.

Highlights of Upbit Upbit is the largest South Korea – based cryptocurrency exchange founded in October 2017 in partnership with Bittrex, the trusted US-based exchange.

Upbit generated $100 million and offers trading with the South Korean won (KRW ).Upfit supports for 359 cryptocurrency pairs and the most active pairs on Upbits are BTC/KRW,XRP/KRW,ETH/KRW and more.

#11 Coinone Clone Script A website script that involves the features and API’s as like coinone cryptocurrency exchange platform.

Highlights of CoinoneCoinone is another South Korea-based exchange that allows users to exchange cryptocurrency. Coinone also supports trading with KRW and for margin trading services.

Coinone has launched Cross – an app utilizing Ripple’s xCurrent product for speedy cross-border payments. Coinone was launched in 2014 and the most active crypto pairs on coinone are BTC/KRW,XRP/KRW,ETH/KRW,etc.,.

#12 Korbit Clone Script A website script that is developed with all the features and plugins of Korbit exchange is known as Korbit clone script.

Highlights of Korbit

Korbit is a leading digital assets exchange launched in 2013 in South Korea. It mainly supports for BTC, ETH and also allows users to buy ripple.

Korbit allows for pairing with KRW and the most active pairing are BTC/KRW, XRP/KRW, ETH/KRW, etc. The trade volume of Korbit exchange is $18,742,383 USD ie., 1,474 BTC.

#13 Bitflyer Clone Script It is a script to develop an exchange as like Bitflyer with lot more additional factors and APIs.

Why like Bitflyer?

As launched in 2014,Bitflyer is a Japan based crypto asset exchange platform that posses the highest trade volume in Japan.It is known for its trustworthiness and low fees, which makes its traders and trade volume higher and higher.

#14 Coincheck Clone Script It is a website script to start your own cryptocurrency exchange as like Coincheck platform.

Why like Coincheck?Coincheck is a Tokyo-based crypto exchange service platform that supports for crypto trading as well as wallet services, launched in 2014.Coincheck is one of the secured platforms to transfer cryptos globally as it involves two-way verification, cold wallet and system security for easy and secured transactions.

#15 Gemini Clone Script

It is a website script that consists of all the characteristic features of the top exchange platform Gemini.

Highlights of GeminiGemini is one of the regulated New-york based crypto exchange Platform that is so safe, powerful, trusted, a faster platform to buy and sell digital currencies.Gemini involves APIs for crypto cybersecurity and it is also known as custodian.

#16 Bitmax Clone ScriptWebsite Script to start a platform like Bitmax.

Highlights of BitmaxBitmax is a cryptocurrency trading platform that supports multi trading platform access.It provides margin trading, minning and other features for their registered traders.Bitmax allows for crypto pairing and most active crypto pairing on Bitmax is BTMX/USDT.

Wikinews discusses DRM and DMCA with Richard Stallman after GitHub re-enables public access to youtube-dl

This article mentions the Wikimedia Foundation, one of its projects, or people related to it. Wikinews is a project of the Wikimedia Foundation.

Wednesday, April 21, 2021

On November 16, code-sharing and hosting service GitHub re-enabled the public access to youtube-dl repository, a software which can download videos from the internet via the command-line. This move comes after Mitchell Stoltz, a Senior Staff Attorney of the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), sent a letter to GitHub on the behalf of youtube-dl’s maintainers. The repository was previously blocked on October 23, after GitHub received a Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) take-down notice from the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA).

Started in July 2008, youtube-dl is a free/libré open source software written in Python which can download videos from various websites. Citing alleged violation of 17 U.S. Code § 1201 Circumvention of copyright protection systems, RIAA’s takedown notice had alleged youtube-dl was intended to circumvent the technological protection measures of streaming services and to redistribute music videos without authorisation. youtube-dl’s source code had a number of unit tests to check if the software works in different circumstances or not. Some of the test cases included URLs of some copyrighted songs.

In the letter to GitHub, EFF’s attorney Stoltz said “This file contains series of automated tests that verify the functionality of youtube-dl for streaming various types of video. The youtube-dl source code does not, of course, contain copies of these songs or any others […] the unit tests do not cause a permanent download or distribution of the songs they reference; they merely stream a few seconds of each song to verify the operation of youtube-dl. Streaming a small portion of a song in a non-permanent fashion to test the operation of an independently created software program is a fair use.” The letter stressed “youtube-dl does not decrypt video streams that are encrypted with commercial DRM technologies”.

The URLs to copyrighted songs were removed from the source code on November 16, and replaced with a test video that uploaded on YouTube by Philipp Hagemeister, former maintainer of youtube-dl. Philipp Hagemeister had previously spoken about the takedown with Wikinews.

youtube-dl comes with a small JavaScript interpreter where it acts as a web-browser would behave while receiving video data from the server. The script has “extractors” for various websites to handle videos from different sources. “Any software capable of running JavaScript code can derive the URL of the video stream and access the stream, regardless of whether the software has been approved by YouTube”, the letter read. It borrowed an analogy of Doors of Durin from J. R. R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings for explanation: travelers come upon a door that has writing in a foreign language. When translated, the writing says “say ‘friend’ and enter.” The travelers say “friend” and the door opens. As with the writing on that door, YouTube presents instructions on accessing video streams to everyone who comes asking for it.

Hours after the public access was restored, Sergey M, one of the maintainers of youtube-dl wrote on GitHub, “We would like to thank @github for standing up for youtube-dl and making it possible to continue development without dropping any features. We appreciate [GitHub] for taking potential legal risks in this regard. We would also like to thank [EFF] and personally [Mitch Stoltz] for invaluable legal help. We would also like to heartily thank our main website hoster Uberspace who is currently being sued in Germany for hosting our essentially business card website and who have already spent thousands of Euros in their legal defense.”

Hours after GitHub restored the public access to the repository, Stoltz tweeted “I think of youtube-dl as a successor to the videocassette recorder. The VCR empowered people to take control of their personal use of free-to-air video, but it had to be saved from the copyright cartel. The same goes for youtube-dl. GitHub did the right thing here.”

youtube-dl is used by thousands of people around the world. Multiple Creative Commons-licensed and public domain videos on Wikimedia Commons are uploaded via a tool called video2commons, which relies on youtube-dl to download media. youtube-dl also lets users download videos from LiveLeak — a video-sharing platform for citizen journalism. Videos downloaded using youtube-dl are also used for the purpose of fair use, or for evidence.

When a copyright holder chooses to release their work, be it a photograph, a video, or audio, under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license, they allow everyone to freely own, share or modify the work as long as the reusers properly attribute the author of the work. YouTube also hosts many audio and video recordings in the public domain which can be used for any purpose without any restrictions.

In the blog post announcing “youtube-dl is back”, GitHub said, “Although we did initially take the project down, we understand that just because code can be used to access copyrighted works doesn’t mean it can’t also be used to access works in non-infringing ways. We also understood that this project’s code has many legitimate purposes, including changing playback speeds for accessibility, preserving evidence in the fight for human rights, aiding journalists in fact-checking, and downloading Creative Commons-licensed or public domain videos.”

GitHub also announced any new 1201 takedown notices will be “carefully scrutinised by legal experts” to reject “unwarranted claims”, and said it will side with software developers if the claims are ambiguous. The announcement also mentioned GitHub Trust and Safety team would treat developer’s tickets as a “top priority”. GitHub also pledged donation of USD 1 million for developer defense fund “to help protect open source developers on GitHub from unwarranted DMCA Section 1201 takedown claims”.

GitHub had blocked public access to many forks of youtube-dl upon receiving the DMCA notice in October. At that time, Wikinews noted public access was not yet restored for the forked repositories listed in RIAA’s copyright notice and was still displays “Repository unavailable due to DMCA takedown”.

During the period when GitHub had disabled public access for the repository, Sergey M had been developing youtube-dl and hosting it on GitLab, another code-sharing and hosting site. However, since GitHub has restored public access of youtube-dl, Sergey M has made the GitLab repository private.

After this, Wikinews reached out to Richard Stallman, the founder of Free Software Foundation, who has been highly critical of DRM (digital rights management, the subject of the DMCA) for many years now, to discuss the harms of DRM and DMCA 1201.

Retrieved from “https://en.wikinews.org/w/index.php?title=Wikinews_discusses_DRM_and_DMCA_with_Richard_Stallman_after_GitHub_re-enables_public_access_to_youtube-dl&oldid=4619261”